Of Ash and Steel Sharpening Minigame Guide: How To Keep The Wheel Green

/ Complete Guide / By

If you’re staring at the sharpening wheel in Of Ash and Steel and thinking “what on earth is this?”, you’re not alone. A lot of players are confused by this minigame and keep getting “Bad” results or 0% sharpening, even when they try to keep the wheel

In this guide I’ll explain the Of Ash and Steel sharpening minigame step by step, in simple ” language, so you actually understand what the game wants from you. No fluff, just how it works, what the UI means, and how to succeed reliably.

We’ll also touch a bit on the other Of Ash and Steel minigames (like fishing and lockpicking) just to give context, but the main focus is sharpening.

Of Ash and Steel Sharpening Minigame Basics

Before touching the wheel, there are a few basic facts about weapon sharpening in Of Ash and Steel:

  • You need a sharpening wheel and usually a sharpening kit or similar resource. These are your tools to improve a weapon’s cutting power.
  • The sharpening minigame is meant to be a skill-based repair/upgrade system, not just a “click once and done” thing. The better you perform, the better the result.
  • The interface is split in two main sides:
    • Left side: direction / input cues (keys or arrows you must follow)
    • Right side: circle or wheel that changes color (your “heat” or “sharpness” zone)

According to players who figured it out and shared on the Steam forums, the core idea is:

Follow the key prompts on the left, and click the mouse until the circle on the right is fully green. Then click at a steady rhythm (about once per second) to keep it there.

So if you were just staring at the circle and randomly clicking, you were missing half the logic: the left side actually matters a lot.

Of Ash and Steel How To Sharpen Weapons Step By Step

Let’s break the Of Ash and Steel how to sharpen weapons process into simple steps you can repeat.

  1. Interact with the sharpening wheel
    • Go up to the wheel and use the interaction key (usually the same as other benches).
    • Make sure the weapon you want to sharpen is equipped or selected in the relevant menu if the game asks.
  2. Watch the prompts on the left side
    • On the left, you’ll see direction keys (like WASD or arrow icons) or some indication telling you how to move/tilt.
    • Your job is to press those keys in time. Think of it like a rhythm + position game:
      • The keys keep your weapon at the correct angle on the wheel.
      • If you ignore them, your sharpening will be “bad” even if the circle looks somewhat green.
  3. Build up the green circle on the right
    • On the right is a circular indicator.
    • As you press the correct keys and click LMB (left mouse button), the circle starts filling and turns green.
    • Your first goal is: make the entire circle green at least once.
    • If you click too slow or press wrong keys, the circle might stay grey/low or move out of the “good” zone.
  4. Maintain the green zone with steady clicks
    • Once the whole circle is green, your job changes from “build up” to “maintain”.
    • Keep pressing the direction keys as indicated on the left.
    • At the same time, click LMB roughly once per second to prevent the circle from:
      • Overheating (if that’s how the system works internally), or
      • Dropping out of the ideal sharpness zone.
    • If you spam click super fast, you might push it out of the good zone. If you never click, it falls back down.
  5. Stop when you’re satisfied
    • After maintaining a good green circle for some time, your sharpening result is set.
    • You’ll usually see feedback like “Good” or a percentage.
    • If you stay in the good zone long enough, your result will be much better than just randomly clicking.

You can think of the minigame as trying to reach the sweet spot (full green circle) and then keep it stable instead of constantly chasing it.

Of Ash and Steel Sharpening Guide: Understanding The UI

A big reason players hate the Of Ash and Steel sharpening minigame is that the game barely explains what the UI means. Let’s decode it.

  1. Left side – input / angle control
    • Those arrows or key icons are not decoration.
    • They represent the angle and pressure of your weapon on the wheel.
    • If you ignore them:
      • You’ll get “Bad” results.
      • The green circle may not fill properly.
    • So treat the left side like a Simon Says game:
      • See the arrow → press that direction.
      • Keep watching, because it might change.
  2. Right side – green circle (sharpness zone)
    • The circle is your performance meter.
    • Colors/states roughly mean:
      • Grey/low fill: You’re not sharpening effectively.
      • Partially green: You’re doing okay, but not at max efficiency.
      • Fully green: This is the ideal sharpening zone where you get the best result.
    • Your goal is to reach and hold the fully green state for as long as is reasonable.
  3. Mouse clicks (LMB) – action timing
    • LMB is not just “start” or “end”; it’s part of the rhythm.
    • While the circle is filling:
      • Repeated LMB clicks help “push” it up.
    • When the circle is fully green:
      • LMB clicks act more like “maintain” taps.
      • About one click every second is what players report as working well.
  4. Why “keeping the wheel green at all time” fails
    • The problem is the phrase “at all time”.
    • If you’re trying to force it:
      • You might over-click.
      • You might ignore the direction keys.
    • The game wants balanced input:
      • Correct keys + steady clicks → stable green.
    • If you focus only on the color and not on the inputs, you’ll fight the system instead of working with it.

Of Ash and Steel Weapon Sharpening Tips and Tricks

Here are practical tips to improve at the Of Ash and Steel weapon sharpening minigame without wasting time and durability.

  1. Focus more on the left than the right
    • Your eyes naturally go to the big circle, but most mistakes come from ignoring the left side key prompts.
    • Get into a habit: left → right → left → right with your eyes.
    • Press directions first, then check if the circle is reacting correctly.
  2. Use a metronome-style rhythm in your head
    • When the circle is fully green, count in your head: “one, click, one, click…” at roughly one click per second.
    • You don’t need perfect timing, just avoid:
      • Machine-gun clicking.
      • Long pauses with no clicks at all.
  3. Don’t panic if the circle drops
    • If the circle starts losing green:
      • Check if you missed a key prompt on the left.
      • Fix your inputs first, then rebuild the circle.
    • It’s better to pause clicking for a moment to correct your keys than to keep clicking blindly.
  4. Practice on a less-important weapon
    • If you’re scared of messing up your best sword, try sharpening a cheaper weapon first.
    • Once your muscle memory is there, you’ll feel way more confident on your main gear.
  5. Watch a short gameplay clip
    • Seeing someone else do the sharpening minigame once can make everything click in your mind.
    • Several gameplay previews and demos show interactions with benches and sharpening wheels; watch how the player times their inputs.

Of Ash and Steel Minigames Explained: Sharpening, Fishing, Lockpicking

The sharpening minigame doesn’t exist alone. Of Ash and Steel has several side activity minigames like fishing, crafting, and lockpicking, all designed to be more immersive and manual instead of simple “Press F to win”.

  • Fishing minigame
    • Players also find this confusing at first.
    • One player explained that the real trick is to watch the button prompts at the top-right, not just the rod or the fish animation:
      • When the indicator blinks/shakes, click to hook.
      • Hold to reel.
      • Press space when the bar is high enough.
  • Lockpicking
    • There are mentions of an “easiest way to lockpick” discussion in the community, so clearly that minigame also has hidden logic that isn’t obvious.
  • Blacksmithing & crafting benches
    • Sharpening is part of a bigger system of blacksmithing, armor reinforcement, and weapon crafting, where each bench has its own interaction style.

The common theme: The game doesn’t hold your hand, and the tutorials are easy to miss or forget. That’s why many people feel the minigames are “bad” at first and only later realize they just needed a proper explanation.

So if you felt dumb for not understanding sharpening, don’t. The UI is not intuitive, and the game assumes you’ll experiment or go online for help.

Common Mistakes In The Of Ash and Steel Sharpening Minigame

Let’s directly attack the biggest pain points players face in the Of Ash and Steel sharpening minigame.

  1. Only watching the green circle
    • Mistake: You try to keep it green by pure clicking, ignoring the prompts.
    • Fix: Train yourself to react to the left side first, then use clicks to support.
  2. Clicking too fast or too randomly
    • Mistake: Treating LMB like a spam button.
    • Fix: Once fully green, slow down to about one click per second and observe how the circle reacts.
  3. Not understanding that filling and maintaining are different phases
    • Mistake: Playing the same way all the time.
    • Fix:
      • Phase 1: Rapid-ish clicks + correct keys → build up to full green.
      • Phase 2: Controlled, steady clicks + correct keys → hold the green.
  4. Giving up after a few bad attempts
    • Mistake: Assuming the system is broken because you see “Bad” or “0%”.
    • Fix: Remember, many players had the exact same complaint before someone explained the trick on the forums.
    • A few tries after understanding the rules usually change your results a lot.

Is Sharpening Worth It In Of Ash and Steel?

After all this effort, is the Of Ash and Steel sharpening minigame actually worth learning?

From what we know about the game’s design philosophy:

  • The game is built around deep RPG systems like hunting, leatherworking, alchemy, blacksmithing, armor reinforcement, and weapon sharpening.
  • These systems are meant to support your build, especially if you enjoy playing a more self-sufficient character who maintains their gear instead of constantly replacing it.
  • A well-sharpened weapon can:
    • Hit harder.
    • Feel more reliable in combat.
    • Help you stretch the life of a favorite weapon before you upgrade to something new.

In short, sharpening is part of that classic RPG vibe where taking care of your gear matters. Once you understand the minigame, it stops feeling like torture and starts feeling like a small, skill-based bonus you can trigger whenever you have access to a wheel.

Final Thoughts: Mastering The Of Ash and Steel Sharpening Minigame

To quickly recap the key points of this Of Ash and Steel sharpening guide:

  • Sharpening is done at a sharpening wheel, often with a sharpening kit.
  • The minigame has two main parts:
    • Left side: follow the direction/key prompts to keep your weapon at the correct angle.
    • Right side: watch the circle and aim to fill it completely with green.
  • First, build up to a fully green circle by combining correct keys with active LMB clicks.
  • Then, maintain the green zone by:
    • Continuing to follow the key prompts.
    • Clicking LMB about once per second instead of spamming.
  • If you were just trying to “keep the wheel green at all time” without understanding the left side, that’s exactly why it felt impossible.
Shopping Cart