Two men from Springfield, Illinois, have been arrested for their alleged roles in a violent 2024 armed robbery at Biaggi’s Italian Restaurant in Bloomington. Nearly a year after the incident, authorities say 21-year-old Bradford House and 23-year-old Autrayvion Haley have both been taken into custody following the issuance of full extradition warrants.
Here’s everything we know about the Bloomington restaurant robbery case, the suspects’ backgrounds, and how the investigation led to their arrests.
When and Where Did the Bloomington Robbery Happen?
According to the Bloomington Police Department, the armed robbery took place on December 9, 2024, at Biaggi’s Italian Restaurant, a well-known dining spot in the city.
Responding officers found evidence of a robbery involving at least two suspects wearing masks, gloves, and dark clothing. One of the suspects reportedly displayed and used a weapon during the incident, escalating what could have been a theft into a violent armed robbery.
The suspects allegedly stole cash and personal property belonging to both employees and the restaurant before fleeing the scene. Fortunately, no one was seriously injured, according to the official police report.
Who Are the Suspects — Bradford House and Autrayvion Haley?
Bradford House (21)
Police confirmed that Bradford House, one of the suspects, was already in custody on unrelated charges at the McLean County Detention Facility when he was officially booked for the Biaggi’s armed robbery.
House faces multiple felony charges, including:
- Armed robbery
- Aggravated robbery
- Robbery
- Burglary
Authorities have not disclosed details about the unrelated charges that originally led to his detention. However, investigators say his alleged involvement in the Bloomington robbery was confirmed through ongoing collaboration between local police and federal law enforcement.
Autrayvion Haley (23)
The second suspect, Autrayvion Haley, was arrested on November 3, 2025, at the Sangamon County Courthouse. His arrest was carried out by a Bloomington Police officer assigned to the U.S. Marshals Service, with assistance from the Sangamon County Sheriff’s Office.
Haley faces the same list of felony charges as House — armed robbery, aggravated robbery, robbery, and burglary.
Both men are currently awaiting extradition and trial proceedings, with prosecutors emphasizing that these arrests mark a major breakthrough in a long-running investigation into the 2024 restaurant robbery.
What Happened During the Biaggi’s Robbery?
Court documents describe a chaotic scene on the night of December 9, 2024, when masked individuals entered Biaggi’s Italian Restaurant shortly before closing time.
Witnesses reported that one suspect brandished a firearm, demanding money from the staff while another suspect collected valuables and cash.
The suspects reportedly took both business funds and employees’ personal belongings, though police have not disclosed the total amount stolen.
After the robbery, both suspects fled on foot, sparking a multi-agency manhunt that continued for months before the case began to break open.
How Police Connected the Suspects to the Crime
Detectives from the Bloomington Police Department, working in partnership with the U.S. Marshals Service, used a combination of forensic evidence, witness statements, and digital data to connect House and Haley to the December 2024 robbery.
Investigators say that physical evidence — including clothing items, weapon-related materials, and surveillance footage — matched the description of the suspects seen on the night of the crime.
Further evidence reportedly linked the two men to stolen property recovered in a later search, strengthening the prosecution’s case.
A Timeline of the Investigation
- December 9, 2024: Armed robbery occurs at Biaggi’s Italian Restaurant in Bloomington.
- Early 2025: Police continue to gather evidence, with no suspects publicly named.
- October 29, 2025: Full extradition arrest warrants issued for Bradford House and Autrayvion Haley.
- October 29, 2025: House arrested while already in custody at McLean County Detention Facility.
- November 3, 2025: Haley arrested at Sangamon County Courthouse with assistance from U.S. Marshals and local deputies.
- November 2025: Both suspects face multiple felony charges as the case moves forward.
No Injuries, But Serious Charges
Although no one was physically injured during the incident, prosecutors have stressed that the use and display of a weapon significantly increases the severity of the charges.
Under Illinois law, armed robbery and aggravated robbery are both Class X felonies, carrying potential prison sentences of 6 to 30 years each.
Legal experts note that, if convicted on multiple counts, both House and Haley could face decades behind bars — especially if the court finds that the robbery involved premeditation or coordination.
Reactions From the Bloomington Community
The Biaggi’s robbery shocked Bloomington residents when it happened nearly a year ago. The restaurant, a family-friendly establishment known for its upscale Italian dining, rarely saw police activity of this kind.
Local customers and staff expressed relief that arrests were finally made. One former employee told reporters:
“We were terrified that night. It’s a miracle nobody got hurt. Knowing they finally caught the suspects brings a lot of peace to everyone who worked there.”
The Bloomington Police Department released a statement thanking the public and partnering agencies for their help in the case, emphasizing that the arrests were “a result of months of detailed investigative work.”
What Happens Next in the Case Against House and Haley?
Both suspects are expected to appear in court later this month for arraignment hearings, where formal charges will be read. The McLean County State’s Attorney’s Office will prosecute the case.
Given the seriousness of the allegations, it’s likely that both men will remain in custody pending trial, particularly since House was already incarcerated and Haley faces multiple felony counts.
If found guilty, both could face lengthy prison sentences and be required to pay restitution to Biaggi’s and its employees for the stolen property and damages.
Similar Cases Across Illinois
The Biaggi’s case is one of several recent armed robberies in Illinois involving restaurants and small businesses. Law enforcement agencies have reported an increase in after-hours burglaries and armed holdups, particularly targeting cash-heavy establishments.
Authorities say they’re using expanded surveillance networks and cross-county task forces to address these patterns more effectively.
Final Thoughts: Justice and Closure for Bloomington
Nearly a year after the Biaggi’s restaurant robbery, the arrests of Bradford House and Autrayvion Haley bring a sense of closure to a case that left employees shaken and the Bloomington community on edge.
While the suspects remain innocent until proven guilty, their arrests mark a crucial milestone in an investigation that stretched across multiple counties and involved local and federal law enforcement cooperation.
As the case proceeds through the court system, Bloomington residents — and Biaggi’s employees — hope that justice will finally be served.
1, Will Todd Snider 2025 Concerts Be Rescheduled After His Arrest?
2, Who Was Elle Jo Kramschuster, the Victim of the Chippewa Falls Jet Ski Crash?
3, Who is Kevin Berrios, Brevard County inmate re-arrested minutes after release?